Windmills and Electricity Supply
Allan Duffy (Press and Journal, August 26), makes a number of assertions and claims which invite challenge.
First, there are far more than a “small number of people” opposing “windfarm sites”.
Second, the cause of this opposition is about more than the potential impact on tourism.
And, finally, they will never generate “excess power” that can be sold to the national grid to enhance Scotland’s economy.
Much of the opposition to windmills relates to their inability to produce electricity when required, combined with their negligible impact on CO emissions because of the expensive associated need for “spinning” back-up from conventional CO-emitting generators.
In his time in Germany, Mr Duffy may have noted that, for all their thousands of windmills, the Germans have not shut down one conventional power station and, in fact, are having to build new coal-fired power stations to meet demand.
If he were to look at the NETA (New Electricity Trading Arrangements) website, he would see that, with all the windmills at present operating in the UK, wind contributes only about 0.1-2% of daily national demand.
Yes, renewable energy must be a component of our future energy mix, but unreliable and expensive windmills are not the answer.
G.M. Lindsay,
Whinfield Gardens,
Kinross, Scotland
Idle Windmills Enrich Some
Yet again, while travelling through the Glens of Foudland, I was struck by a distinct lack of movement by even one of the many wind turbines you drive past.
Another bad day in Scotland’s fight against global warming… sorry, I forgot for a moment that climate change seems to have been adopted as a more appropriate term now.
In the meantime, the landowners, renewable-energy companies – through massive subsidies – and overseas manufacturers of said turbines continue to get rich at the expense of the taxpayer. Strange times indeed.
Chris Davis,
Maryhill, Orton,
Fochabers, Scotland
Source: http://www.pressandjournal.co.uk/Article.aspx/1890438/
RSS